| H. Cleveland | Feb 1837 to Apr 1839 |
| M. Winburn | Apr 1839 to May 1840 |
| J. Catlin | Jun 1840 to Feb 1840 |
| B. Grayson | Feb 1843 to Feb 1845 |
| C. Railey | Feb 1845 to Dec 1845 |
| A. Robinson | Dec 1845 to Oct 1848 |
| J. Jackson | Oct 1840 to Aug 1850 |
| A. Bell | Aug 1850 to Aug 1852 |
| J. Jackson | Aug 1852 to Aug 1854 |
| J. Edwards | Aug 1854 to Aug 1856 |
| G. Johnson | Aug 1856 to Aug 1858 |
| J. Jackson | Aug 1858 to Aug 1862 |
| G. Bell | Aug 1862 to Apr 1864 |
| J. Ferrell | Ex-Officio |
| N. Cloyd | Aug 1864 to Jun 1866 |
| T. Luhn | Jun 1866 to Aug 1867 |
| J. Smith | Acting |
| F. Palm | Jan 1868 to Jun 1869 |
| A. John | May 1869 to Jun 1869 |
| W. Green | Jun 1869 to Oct 1872 |
| J. Blasingame | Nov 1872 to Dec 1873 |
| C. Langhammer | Dec 1873 to Nov 1878 |
| J. Lewis | Nov 1878 to Nov 1890 |
| W. Glenn | Nov 1890 to Nov 1896 |
| W. Palm | Nov 1896 to Oct 1918 |
| J. Palm | Oct 1918 to Oct 1918 |
| L. Johnston | Nov 1918 to Nov 1920 |
| A. Remmert | Nov 1920 to April 1932 |
| G. Koy | Apr 1932 to Mar 1937 |
| E. Reinecker | Mar 1937 to Jan 1948 |
| M. Steck | Nov 1948 to Jan 1953 |
| T. Maddox | Nov 1952 to Sep 1987 |
| V. Brzozowski | Sep 1987 to Dec 1995 |
| R. Burger | Jan 1996 to Dec 2012 |
| J. Brandes | Jan 2013 to Present |